Plateaux: What a Tennis Novel Can Teach Experienced Athletes About the Next Level

Socrates is credited with saying that “the unexamined life is not worth living”. 2,300 years later, his message persists. If you've been in this sport a while, you've crossed some finish lines, and you've probably had a season or two where everything clicked and the numbers moved every time you tested. And then, at some point, they stopped moving. You kept training, maybe harder than ever, and the results flattened out. That flat stretch is what athletes and coaches call a plateau: a period where performance stops improving even though the training continues. It's usually the moment most worth examining, and one of the best lenses I've found for it comes from an unlikely place: a work of fiction.

An academy, a lecture and a word with an X

A portion of David Foster Wallace's Infinite Jest is about a Boston-based youth tennis academy, which prepares young athletes to become very high-level tennis players, not dissimilar to the general mindsets of many of our own athletes. The kids there are serious about the sport, they're ranked, and they're constantly measured against one another, so the question of who keeps improving and who doesn't is never far from anyone's mind. One passage in particular speaks to the climb towards mastery of a skill - in this case tennis - and categorizes the ‘hows’ and ‘whys’ of the pitfalls that occur along the way, amongst those who do not achieve mastery. When I originally read it, in the book, I saw it from the coaching perspective.

The scene itself is small. A handful of students sit cross-legged on the floor while one of them, working from index cards, explains a theory of mastery that belongs to one of the academy's older players, who is leaning against the door stretching his neck and listening. The heart of the theory is that real progress is “slow, frustrating. Humbling. A question of less talent than temperament.” Nobody improves in a straight line. You improve quickly up to a certain level, and then you stall, sometimes for a long time. That stall is the plateau, and the passage is clear that there's no shortcut off it: “the only way to get off one of the plateaus and climb up to the next one up ahead is with a whole lot of frustrating mindless repetitive practice and patience and hanging in there.” The older player, still staring at the ceiling, interrupts only to correct the spelling, half joking: it's plateaux, with an X.

Note what that theory leaves out. It doesn't say mastery belongs to the most gifted kid, or the one who works the most hours. It says progress comes in steps, the steps are separated by long flat stretches, and what gets you from one step to the next is mostly a matter of character: the humility to accept that you are not necessarily seeing the improvement right now, the patience to keep doing the work anyway, the temperament to stay level when the results don't come, and the plain willingness to hang in there until they do. Then the passage turns to the kids who don't make it, and sorts them into three types.

The first is the Despairing type. He does just fine during the quick-improvement stage, when every week brings something new. But when he reaches a plateau and feels himself stall, improving more slowly or even getting a little worse, he “gives in to frustration and despair”. He doesn't have the humility or the patience to sit with a flat stretch, and he can't stand the time a plateau demands. So he bails. When the speaker asks what happens to this type, the other kids shout the answer together, because everyone already knows.

The second is the Obsessive type, and he's the mirror image. He's so eager to hop to the next plateau that patience and humility never enter the picture. When he stalls, he tries to force his way off the plateau through sheer will, more drilling, more hours, more work, done more and more frantically, until “he overdoes it and gets hurt”. Then he keeps going on a body that's breaking down, hobbling around the court, still overworking, until he can barely play and his ranking collapses. His story ends with a knock on the door from one of the academy staff, wanting the same little chat about his progress.

The third is the Complacent type, and the passage calls him maybe the worst of the three, because his problem “can cunningly masquerade as patience and humble frustration”. He improves dramatically, reaches a plateau, and is perfectly content there. It's comfortable and familiar, so he never really tries to leave. Over time he designs his whole game around compensating for the weaknesses that plateau represents, and meanwhile the players he used to beat find those weak spots and start beating him. He says he doesn't care, that he's in it for the love of the game, and he stays friendly and pleasant to be around, but his smile gets a little tight while everyone else moves up. His story ends the same way: a quiet knock at the door.

Because the passage is heavy on the three categories of how and where failure occurs, it is easy to overlook the language around how success occurs. It being a function of humility, “patience”, “temperament” and “just hanging in there”. That's the part I'd ask you to hold onto, because it's exactly what the next level asks of an experienced athlete.

Now read it again, this time as an athlete

Now that you have read the above, please take a moment to read it again. This time from a very different perspective: yours. These are just singular examples of what could be an infinite (pun intended) number of potential possibilities, but all three types are easy to find in endurance sports.

The Despairing athlete chases a big goal, a qualifying slot or a breakthrough time, partly because it's kind of like “the thing to do”. Then the work starts, and they realize how truly difficult it is, because the reality of the true measure of how badly you want to do something is much less about the end result of having done it, and more about how much you are willing to ‘suffer’ in order to actually achieve it. In essence, are you willing to “embrace the grind”? When the first real plateau arrives, this athlete changes plans, changes approach or changes goals, and starts the quick-improvement stage all over again.

The Obsessive athlete wants the result so badly that they add sessions nobody asked for, try to make up every missed workout, push the efforts that are meant to be controlled, and pile on more training than they can absorb. They end up frustrated and extremely over-worked, and they get nowhere near a return that is in any way commensurate with their efforts. Sooner or later, the body does the ‘knocking on the door’, so to speak.

The Complacent athlete trains around philosophies that always just really worked for him or her: the same weekly routine, the same races, the same pacing. The numbers feel fine, so there's no reason to retest or rethink, and little by little their whole race is built around the plateau they're standing on. Of the three, that's the one that looks most like patience. It isn't.

How QT2.0 is built for the plateau

QT2.0 is the system we use to coach every QT2 athlete. At its core it's a decision-making system, built to create measurable performance change by getting the most return from the training you put in. It rests on four connected documents: our Principles, which describe how we think about coaching; the Decision-Making Framework, which chooses what kind of training you need next; StressLogic, which decides how much training stress to apply each week; and our day-to-day coaching standards. The standard running through all four is simple: at any point, your coach should be able to explain what you're doing, when you're doing it, and why it is the right move for you right now. That turns out to be a good defense against all three types, because each one is really just a decision problem dressed up as a personality.

The first decision is an honest measure of where you are. On the bike we use Critical Power, and on the run, Critical Speed. Each marks the boundary between effort your body can sustain in a stable way and effort where it starts drawing on limited anaerobic reserves. In practice, it's around the hardest effort most athletes can hold for roughly 25 to 70 minutes, depending on the athlete and the sport. Your training zones are built as percentages of those two numbers, so if Critical Power or Critical Speed is wrong, every intensity built on it is wrong too, and so is every decision that follows. That's why we update them every six to eight weeks, or when new test results come in, and why we don't raise the numbers after one great workout, during heavy fatigue or illness, or as a reward. They describe your current working fitness, not your potential, and when they drop for a real reason, the lower number goes in right away. That honesty is the antidote to the Complacent athlete's comfortable fiction, and it's what lets a plateau be seen clearly enough to do something about.

The second decision is what kind of plateau it is, and for that we picture your bike or run fitness as a house. The roof is your power or speed at VO2 Max, the most oxygen your body can use, which we estimate from a hard effort of about three minutes (pVO2 Max on the bike, sVO2 Max on the run). The ceiling is your Critical Power or Critical Speed, what you can sustain. The gap between them is the attic space. When the attic is large, your sustainable fitness sits well below your capacity, and the best return usually comes from raising the ceiling, through an Aerobic Expansion (AE) or Build/TH (BTH) block. When the ceiling is already pressed up near the roof, there's little room left to raise it, so the better return usually comes from raising the roof first, through a VO2 Max (VO2) block. A block, in our terms, is a stretch of training with one primary job. Practical reality still sets the boundaries: a new season, a return from injury or a concern about durability (holding your fitness late in a long race) points to Base/Durability (BD), and the final weeks before a key race point to Specificity (SP), which focuses on executing at the intensity that race will demand. Block selection is not preference. Block selection is a decision. We solve one primary problem at a time, and when a block has done its job, we change the stimulus rather than stretching it out. That's how you move off a plateau on purpose, instead of by force or by accident.

And because the house is a snapshot of where you are now, not a label for who you are, a stall is information, not a verdict, which is the thing the Despairing athlete most needs to hear.

The third decision is how much to do each week, and that's StressLogic's job. It works in Training Stress Score (TSS), a measure of training load that accounts for workout duration and intensity. We track TSS separately for each discipline, so we can see how much stress you're accumulating in the swim, on the bike, and on the run, though swimming sits outside StressLogic. Each week, StressLogic sets your bike and run TSS by asking one question: what's the most appropriate training stress you can absorb right now? It weighs your recent load alongside how training is actually landing, including sleep, soreness, motivation, mood and life stress, and then makes one of five calls: Big Push, Small Push, Hold Steady, Small Pull Back, or Big Pull Back. No single signal decides the week; the pattern does. Missed workouts aren't made up, overcooked workouts aren't paid back, and we don't force progression because a calendar said so. We forge onward. That's the direct answer to the Obsessive type. The goal is adaptation, not accumulation. I’ll say that again, because it is one of the most important principles that we hold. The goal is adaptation, not accumulation. You are pushed, but not crushed, and consistency beats heroics.

Underneath all three decisions is intent. Every workout has a purpose, and the structure exists to express that purpose, not to handcuff you. Perfection is not required. Intentionality is. Done that way, the repetitive practice the novel describes isn't mindless at all. It is anything but. The training isn’t built to entertain you. It is built to squeeze the maximal amount of potential out of you. Training that is built to entertain has a different kind of purpose, but performance optimization typically isn’t it. What we build instead is patient, purposeful work with a clear job, reviewed by a coach who's paying attention.

Humility, patience, temperament and hanging in there

So here are the questions I'd ask you to sit with this off-season, the same ones I ask of myself.

  • Where are you trying too hard?
  • Where are your efforts so great that they are actually inefficient and/or detrimental?
  • Are there things you just do too much of, with little or no direct or indirect return?
  • Where are you being thrown off, diverted, or otherwise giving up due to obstacles and hurdles in your way?
  • Where have you settled for ‘good enough’?

That last one is not a trick question. Sometimes ‘good enough’ can be ‘good enough’, at least for a little while. Not every weakness needs attacking this season, and solving one primary problem at a time means deliberately leaving others alone. But be honest about whether ‘good enough’ is a choice or a habit, and watch for the decay of ‘good enough’, such that it becomes an eventual victim of Complacency. As we’ve discussed, above, Complacency can sometimes look and act like patience and humility and temperament.

The athletes who keep moving up aren't usually the most talented ones. They're the ones with the temperament to do the slow work, the humility to let honest numbers tell them where they are, and the patience to hang in there while a good decision takes time to show up. If you'd like a coach making those decisions with you, week by week, that's what QT2.0 1-1 Coaching is built for. Start a conversation with a QT2 coach.

Back to blog